1. Science
  2. Publications
  3. Science and Technology of the Air Force of Ukraine
  4. 4(37)'2019
  5. Indicators and criteria for evaluating the efficiency of deploying the task force of the National guards of Ukraine to localize the area of the armed conflict of a non-international character

Indicators and criteria for evaluating the efficiency of deploying the task force of the National guards of Ukraine to localize the area of the armed conflict of a non-international character

S. Hodlevskyi
Annotations languages:


Description: The paper substantiates the indicators and criteria for evaluating the effectiveness of the National Guard of Ukraine grouping for localization of the armed conflict of a non-international character area, which correspond to the nature and condi-tions of such conflict localization tasks. Method of system analysis was used for determining of functional elements of the Na-tional Guard task force, which are to be evaluated. To find the key indicators of performance and effectiveness, multicriteria problem solving method was applied. It is concluded that it is impossible to use the classic indicators and criteria for the evalua-tion of hostilities, but instead there is a need to develop and justify specific, which correspond to the peculiarities of the tasks in the conditions of the armed conflict of a non-international character. Validated requirements for metrics and classifies them into performance and effectiveness metrics, input and output indicators. The scientific novelty of the results obtained, in contrast to the known ones, is the use of indicators and criteria in the new combination and interconnection; taking into account the func-tional purpose of the echelons of the National Guard task force and the levels of military management when choosing indicators and evaluation criteria. In addition, the Harrington Verbal Numeric Scale was used for the first time to evaluate the baseline qualitative indicators that characterize the success of the task force as a whole, which greatly increases the objectivity and ade-quacy of evaluating its effectiveness. Contribution to the development of the theory of operational art in the field of localization of the armed conflict of a non-international character was made. The set of indicators and criteria developed allows adequately assessing the effectiveness of the National Guard task force as a whole and by it separate elements, and, at the same time can be used in the practice of commanders and headquarters to plan the execution of tasks, as well as to promptly and reasonably adjust the decisions and plans developed when performing counterinsurgency missions.


Keywords: performance indicators and criteria, guard task force, localization of armed conflict of a non-international character, counterinsurgency operation.

References

1.Campbell, Jason, O'Hanlon, Michael E. and Shapiro, Jacob (2011), How to Measure the War, Policy Review, No. 157,October-November 2009b, available at: www.hoover.org/publications/policy-review/article/5490 (accessed 30 June 2011).
2.Anderson, Edward G., Jr. (2011), A Dynamic Model of Counterinsurgency Policy Including the Effects of Intelligence,Public Security, Popular Support, and Insurgent Experience, System Dynamics Review, Vol. 27, No. 2, pp. 111-141.
3.Carpenter, P. Mason, and Andrews, William F. (2009), Effects-Based Operations: Combat Proven, Joint Force Quar-terly, No. 52, pp. 78-81.
4.Meharg, Sarah Jane (2009), Measuring Effectiveness in Complex Operations: What Is Good Enough, Canadian Defenceand Foreign Affairs Institute, Calgary.
5.Maslov, A. (2016), Measuring the Performance of the Police: research report: 2015–R034, available at:https://www.publicsafety.gc.ca/cnt/rsrcs/pblctns/2015-r034/index-en.aspx.
6.Etienne, Vincent, Eles, Philip and Vasiliev, Boris (2010), Opinion Polling in Support of Counterinsurgency, CornwallisGroup XIV: Analysis of Societal Conflict and Counter Insurgency, Cornwallis Group, pp. 104-125, available at: www.thecornwallisgroup.org/cornwallis_2009/7-Vincent_etal-CXIV.pdf (accessed 1 April 2011).
7.Bezhentseva, T.V., Aleksandrova, N.N. and Matyus, E.G. (2018), Formation of system of indicators for evaluation ofenvironmental activities, IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering. 451. 012182. https://doi.org/10.1088/1742-6596/451/1/012182.
8.Kazakov, A. (2018), “O nekotorykh podkhodakh k oczenke e`ffektivnosti operativno-rozy`sknoj deyatel`nosti na Gosu-darstvennoj granicze v bor`be s nezakonnoj migracziej” [On some approaches to assessing the effectiveness of operational-search activities at the State Border in the fight against illegal migration], Collection of scientific articles of the Military Academy of the Republic of Belarus, No. 34, pp. 77-84.
9.Litavor, O. and Rudozub, G. (2015), “Metodika oczenki e`ffektivnosti primeneniya territorial`nykh vojsk” [Methodol-ogy for assessing the effectiveness of the use of territorial troops], Bulletin of the Military Academy of the Republic of Belarus, No. 3(48), pp. 77-84.
10.Dubnitskiy, V., Zubrytska, H. and Kobylin, A. (2018), “Yntervaljnoe ocenyvanye kolychestva uchastnykov massovykhprotestnykh akcyj” [Interval estimation of the number of participants of mass protest actions], Advanced Information Systems, No. 2(4), pp. 11-20. https://doi.org/10.20998/2522-9052.2018.4.02.
11.Babkov,Yu. and Adamchuk, M. (2015), “Pokaznyky i kryterii otsiniuvannia efektyvnosti zastosuvannia uhrupovanviisk (syl) Natsionalnoi hvardii Ukrainy” [Indicators and criteria for assessing the effectiveness of the National Guard of Ukraine (troop) units], Scientific Works of Kharkiv National Air Force University, No. 2(43), pp. 13-18.
12.Batsamut,V. and Holovan, O. (2015), “Aspekty otsiniuvannia stanu operatyvnoi obstanovky u sferi okhoronyhromadskoho poriadku ta zabezpechennia hromadskoi bezpeky orhanamy viiskovoho upravlinnia Natsionalnoi hvardii Ukrainy”[Aspects of assessing the state of the operational situation in the field of public order and ensuring public security by the military guards of the National Guard of Ukraine], Scientific Works of Kharkiv National Air Force University, No. 3(44), pp. 122-127.
13.Hodlevskyi, S. (2019), “Metodyka obgruntuvannia ratsionalnoho boiovoho skladu uhrupovannia Natsionalnoi hvardiiUkrainy dlia lokalizatsii raionu zbroinoho konfliktu nemizhnarodnoho kharakteru” [The methodology of .ationale of the eficient combat composition of the National guard of Ukraine task force to localize a zone of non-international armed conflict], Honor and Law, No. 3(70), NANGU, Kharkiv, pp. 41-52.

Reference:
 Hodlevskyi, S.O. (2019), “Pokaznyky ta kryterii otsiniuvannia efektyvnosti zastosuvannia uhrupovannia Natsionalnoi hvardii Ukrainy dlia lokalizatsii raionu zbroinoho konfliktu nemizhnarodnoho kharakteru” [Indicators and criteria for evaluating the efficiency of deploying the task force of the National Guards of Ukraine to localize the area of the armed conflict of a non-international character], Science and Technology of the Air Force of Ukraine, No. 4(37), pp. 122-131. https://doi.org/10.30748/nitps.2019.37.17.