1. Science
  2. Publications
  3. Science and Technology of the Air Force of Ukraine
  4. 4(37)'2019
  5. Approach to shaping kriter device of the estimation to efficiency of the mixed groups piloted and unmanned aviation

Approach to shaping kriter device of the estimation to efficiency of the mixed groups piloted and unmanned aviation

I. Klushnikov, V. Nerubatsky, A. Shalyhin
Annotations languages:

Description: The subject of research is the evaluation of the effectiveness of aviation. The aim of the work is to determine a system of in-dicators and criteria for assessing the effectiveness of the use of mixed groups of piloted and unmanned aircraft. The article shows that an aviation group consisting of manned and unmanned aircraft is essentially a combat system that is designed to con-duct armed combat. The set of mathematical expectations of the number of enemy assets that will be destroyed during the per-formance of combat missions, and their means that can be destroyed, satisfy the basic requirements for the performance indica-tors of combat systems. The totality of these indicators reveals in detail the process of conducting and the results of the armed struggle, but does not allow the selection of the most acceptable options for the application or construction of a combat system. In this regard, it is advisable to combine (collapse) private indicators in the generalized indicators of causing losses to the enemy and their losses. For convolution, weight factors of the opponent’s own funds and assets are used. These weighting factors can have different meanings, which depend on the purpose of the application of the mixed aviation group. They can display the cost of funds, or the operational-tactical importance when completing a mission, or the value of a critical resource for continuing an armed struggle. The article defines a methodological approach to the formation of a system of indicators and criteria for assess-ing the effectiveness of mixed groups of piloted and unmanned aircraft based on the application of the general laws of armed struggle. The indicated system of indicators and criteria can be used to solve the problem of choosing appropriate options for the combined use of units (units) of manned and unmanned aircraft and to select appropriate options (alternatives) for creating a mixed group of units (units) of manned and unmanned aerial vehicles.

Keywords: grouping of piloted and unmanned aircraft, performance indicators and criteria for assessing effectiveness, warfare, joint use, selection of preferred options (alternatives).


1. Strel'nikov, D. (2017), “Kontseptual'nyye vzglyady komandovaniya VVS SSHA na razvitiye bespilotnoy aviatsii” [The conceptual views of the US Air Force command on the development of unmanned aircraft], Foreign military review, No. 5, p.p. 51-61.
2. Winnefeld, James A. and Kendall, Frank (2013), Unmanned Systems Integrated Roadmap FY2013-2038, available at: https://archive.defense.gov/pubs/dod-usrm-2013.pdf.
3. Headquarters, United States Air Force (2009), United States Air Force Unmanned Aircraft Systems Flight Plan 2009-2047, available at: https://fas.org/irp/program/collect/uas_2009.pdf.
4. Headquarters, United States Air Force (2014), The United States Air Force Remotely Piloted Aircraft Vector: Vision and Enabling Concepts: 2013-2038, available at: https://www.af.mil/Portals/1/documents/news/ USAFRPAVectorVisionandEnablingConcepts2013-2038.pdf.
5. Headquarters, United States Air Force (2015), Small Unmanned Aircraft Systems Flight Plan: 2016-2036, available at: https://apps.dtic.mil/dtic/tr/fulltext/u2/1013675.pdf.
6. Strel'nikov, D., Sidorov, A. and Mgimov, Yu. (2018), “Sovmestnoye primeneniye pilotiruyemoy i bespilotnoy aviatsii SSHA v pervoy polovine XXI veka” [Combined use of manned and unmanned aerial vehicles of the USA in the first half of the 21st century], Foreign military review, No. 4, pp. 52-59.
7. Lazebnyk, S.V., Malyuha, V.H. and Nerubatsʹkyy, V.O. (2012), “Pidkhid do formuvannya systemy pokaznykiv efektyvnosti uhrupovanʹ viysʹk” [Approach to formation of system of indicators of efficiency of groups of troops], Scientific works of Kharkov National Air Forces University, No. 4(33), pp. 5-8.
8. Barvinenko, V.V. and Anoshko, Yu.G. (2014), “Yeshche raz o pokazatelyakh i kriteriyakh” [Once again on indicators and criteria], Aerospace Defense, No. 3, available at: www.vko.ru/koncepcii/eshche-raz-o-pokazatelyah-i-kriteriyah.
9. Bonin, A.S. (2014), “Metodika obosnovaniya potrebnogo sostava aviatsionnoy gruppirovki na strategicheskom napravlenii v operatsiyakh nachal'nogo perioda voyny” [Methodology for substantiating the required composition of an aviation group on a strategic direction in operations of the initial period of the war], Bulletin of the Academy of Military Sciences, No. 3(48), pp. 39-42.
10. Lotov, A.V. and Pospelova, I.I. (2008), “Mnogokriterialnyye zadachi prinyatiya resheniy” [Multicriteria tasks of decision-making], MAX Press, Moscow, 197 p.
11. Biryukov, A.N. (2010), “Multiplikativno-additivnaya svertka chastnykh kriteriyev-agregatov dlya otsenki effektivnosti raboty uchrezhdeniy zdravookhraneniya” [Multiplicative-additive convolution of partial criteria-aggregates for evaluation of the efficiency of health care institutions], Administration of economic systems, No. 4, available at: www.uecs.ru/logistika/item/275-2011-03-25-06-56-54.
12. Zak, Yu.A. (2014), “Prikladnyye zadachi mnogokriterialnoy optimizatsii” [Applied problems of multicriteria optimization], Economics, Moscow, 455 p.
13. Zak, Yu.A. (2013), “Prinyatiye resheniy v usloviyakh nechetkikh i razmytykh dannykh: Fuzzy-tekhnologii” [Decision-making in the context of fuzzy and diffused data: Fuzzy technology], Librokom, Moscow, 352 p.
14. Kruglov, V. and Dymov, S. (2002), “Voyennaya sistemologiya kak nauchnyy metod” [Military systemology as a scien-tific method], Observer, No. 1(144), available at: www.old.nasledie.ru/oboz/N01_02/1_11.HTM.

 Kliushnikov, I.M., Nerubatskyi, V.O. and Shalyhin, A.A. (2019), “Pidkhid do formuvannia kryterialnoho aparatu otsinky efektyvnosti zmishanykh uhrupovan pilotovanoi ta bezpilotnoi aviatsii” [Approach to shaping kriter device of the estimation to efficiency of the mixed groups piloted and unmanned aviation], Science and Technology of the Air Force of Ukraine, No. 4(37), pp. 50-55. https://doi.org/10.30748/nitps.2019.37.07.